Why Women Are More Depressed than Men

Image for post
Image for post

A study reported that despite improvement in women’s lives, their happiness relative to men has declined since the ’70s, when the reverse was true. This held true across racial and socio-economic lines in several industrialized countries. Women’s happiness also declines with age. In contrast, men’ happiness has increased and increases with age.

Some attribute the decline in women’s happiness to the demands of work and motherhood, but research shows that working women and working mothers are happier. Work outside the home provides stimulation and another identity that protects against depression.

Another theory suggests that the women’s movement raised women’s expectations, and reality has failed to deliver. Today, many more women are college-educated and seek professions previously reserved for men, but then hit the glass ceiling. Moreover, old cultural beliefs that undermine women’s self-esteem are slow to change.

Women are more highly educated now and jobs may have opened up, but many women lack the instrumental qualities of self-efficacy, assertiveness, and autonomy that generate self-esteem and professional success. It’s not surprising that independent and assertive women are less depressed. Some women incorrectly believe that being assertive and autonomous will jeopardize their relationships, a priority for women. Not surprisingly, women who suppress their anger are more subject to depression.

I believe that current culture contributes to our unhappiness. A University of Michigan study found that college students are about 40 percent less empathetic than were coeds 20–30 years ago. Social networking, new technologies and speed, though affording many benefits, have also decreased the amount of time people spend with each other — dancing, socializing, and even watching television together. More time online means less time with others, in nature, or pursuing crafts and hobbies. Innovations and gadgets that feed men starve the feminine. Picture Aphrodite online!

The signs of depression are feelings of sadness, worthlessness, and/or guilt, crying, loss of interest in usual activities, fatigue, difficulty concentrating, irritability, social withdrawal, and changes in sleep, weight, or appetite.

Ten to 25% of women will experience major depression in their lifetime. Each depressive episode makes another more likely. Rather than building resilience, we become more vulnerable and sensitive. Depression may be acute, lasting several weeks, or it may be less severe but chronic, lasting years, called dysthymia, which is common with codependency.

Risks for depression among women include the following:

1. Passive, dependent, and pessimistic personality traits.

2. Sexual or physical abuse. (Chronic verbal abuse impacts our self-esteem and mood also.)

3. Having several, young children.

4. Poverty.

5. Inability to have children that they want.

6. Being a new mother. Post-partum depression occurrs in 10–15 percent of new mothers, and 80 percent have “baby blues.” This is now considered a familial issue.

7. Work overload.

8. Hormone changes due to menses and effects of perimenopause and menopause.

Gender Differences

Not surprisingly, research shows that women are twice as likely as men to experience depression and have higher co-morbid rates of combined anxiety and depression. After heart disease, depression is the most debilitating illness for women, while it’s tenth for men.

This gender difference with males first appears at puberty, arguably due to hormonal changes. But Harvard professor Ronald Kessler attributes the shift to girls’ lower self-esteem, described in my blog on “Self-Criticism­ — Self-Esteem’s Saboteur.” It’s also impaired by lack of self-efficacy in reaching our goals. Low self-esteem and accompanying negative self-talk lead to depression.

Another difference from men is that more women live in poverty and suffer greater discrimination and abuse. Those physically or sexually abused account for half of depressed women. Additionally, our brains are different from men’s. We synthesize 52% less of mood-elevating serotonin, and our estrogen increases the amount of cortisol, a stress hormone. Hard-wired for emotional and empathetic responses, we are more sensitive to loss of attachment and problems at home and with children.

A significant loss, such as divorce, doubles a woman’s risk of depression. Whereas men distract themselves to cope with loss and pain, the fact that we have better recall than they do, and in more vivid detail, contributes to our greater rumination of painful events. Greater rumination and self-criticism cause greater depression. If women coped like men, the incidence of depression between genders would be the same.

Women are much more likely to be diagnosed and misdiagnosed with depression by male clinicians, and they are over-prescribed medication — 82% more than men are given anti-depressants.

If you are or have been depressed in the past, develop a strong support system, which can protects against depression and helps you recover from it. It’s important to develop good coping strategies and beliefs to deal with stress and negative life events. Becoming more autonomous and assertive leads to greater happiness and empowerment, while protecting against depression.

Therapy can assist in all of these areas; with treatment, 80% of people improve. Depression is an illness affecting brain chemistry. Often the source is shame originating in childhood. Self-blame is typical with depression, so don’t let guilt or shame stop you from getting help needed to recover, as you would for any physical illness.

Take these five evidence-based actions to lift your mood and Raise Your Self-Esteem. If you’re dealing with shame, do the steps in Conquering Shame and Codependency: 8 Steps to Freeing the True You.

Copyright © Darlene Lancer, LMFT 2010, 2019

Therapist-Author of “Codependency for Dummies,” relationship expert. Get a FREE 14 Tips on Letting Go http://bit.ly/MN2jSG. Join me on FB http://on.fb.me/WnMQMH

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store